This morning, after three years on the job, Arena Football League commissioner Scott Butera was replaced by Randall Boe, the executive vice president of Monumental Sports & Entertainment. Butera’s administration was marred by only three expansion franchises against 11 teams that were either shut down or relocated to other leagues.
Perhaps no mark was blacker on his tenure then when he told the league-owned Las Vegas Outlaws that they would be allowed to play in the playoffs if they qualified, only to shut them down the day after clinching a playoff spot.
One other black mark on his tenure was his failure to bring the Arena League back to San Antonio, TX. He was nearly a month into his job when the league made official the news to shut down the team. He was quoted at the time as saying “San Antonio is a very desirable city for the AFL and efforts will continue to bring Arena Football back to the Alamo City; The AFL has the utmost appreciation for the passion and support Talons fans have shown their team and we look forward to returning to San Antonio.”
However, nothing ever came to fruition. In 2015, Butera and the Spurs were on the brink of bringing back the Talons, only for the Spurs to back out at the last moment due to instability in the league at the time.
Butera even managed to visit San Antonio and the Spurs in March 2016 and talk to them about bringing back a team, but not even that was enough to make it a reality. Along the way, the Cleveland Gladiators, a team that is owned by Dan Gilbert, owner of the NBA’s Cleveland Cavaliers, announced they would be taking two years off due to arena renovations. A month later, the Tampa Bay Storm announced they would suspend operations, becoming the second NBA/NHL owned team that would not play in 2018.
This news is a blow to the hopes of the AFL returning to San Antonio. Butera was the commissioner that emphasized NBA and NHL owners joining the AFL. While he was only able to bring in one, he had talks with Spurs Sports And Entertainment and had hope of restoring a team in the Alamo City.
Not much is known about Boe and what kinds of ownership groups he will try to attract to the AFL, but the [temporary] loss of the Gladiators and the permanent loss of the Storm has hurt the chances of this dream ever coming true, and with Butera gone, those chances get worse with every passing day.